Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Plain
Chicken Tender
Fisherman Platter
Shrimp Platter
About
Vinny's Pizzeria
Situated in the heart of Croghan, New York, Vinny's Pizzeria is not just another pizza joint; it’s a culinary haven for pizza lovers. Located at 9786 NY-812, this charming pizzeria has quickly garnered a reputation as the go-to spot for unmatched pizza experiences in Lewis County.
From the moment you step in, the inviting atmosphere radiates warmth and hospitality. The teammates at Vinny's are friendly and genuinely care about your dining experience. Whether you're a local or just passing through, the welcoming vibe makes you feel right at home.
But let’s talk about the food—oh, the food! According to many thrilled patrons, Vinny's pizza is considered a true masterpiece. One delighted customer, Ginger Button, raves, "This is the best pizza we have ever had." The praises continue, highlighting the perfect balance of a non-greasy, crisp crust paired with a delightful amount of sauce that tantalizes the taste buds. Every bite is a celebration, with plentiful toppings that never compromise on quality.
Furthermore, the menu extends beyond pizza. The chicken parm sandwich is a standout, delivering crunchy bread, fresh chicken, and excellent sauce that leaves you wanting more. The attention to detail, like the small piece of broccoli left on a calzone for garnish, as noted by Default Bandaid, showcases Vinny's commitment to customer service and culinary presentation.
For anyone searching for an unforgettable pizza experience, Vinny's Pizzeria tops the list. The crispiness of their crust, the rich flavor of their sauce, and the perfect melt of cheese create a symphony of taste in every bite. If you haven't made the journey to Vinny's yet, make a plan to do so—your taste buds will thank you. As Christine Purpura aptly puts it, "Every bite is better than the last." With each visit, you're not just a guest; you’re part of the Vinny's family.
With a phone number of +1 315-346-1444, getting in touch with Vinny’s is easy for take-out orders or quick questions. So why wait? Treat yourself to the best pizza experience around at Vinny's Pizzeria today!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Best pizza around! Vinny's pizza is an edible masterpiece. Their crispy crust combined with a deliciously flavored sauce and pefectly melted cheese is the way pizza should be. Ever bite is better than the last. The staff is friendly and welcoming and there is a truly family atmosphere there. I will gladly take the drive to visit Vinny's again. ”
“ Had a chicken parm sandwich that tasted great. Crunchy bread, fresh chicken and good sauce. I was driving thru on my way back to NYC. Nice people working there. ”
“ The pizza is great! Also got a meatball and cheese sub that was amazing! The sub roll was sooo soft yet held together and wasn't soggy when you get around to the 2nd half. They tasted freshly made in house!! Will be back often! ”
“ This is the best pizza we have ever had. We have experienced great, good, and moderate to gross pizzas in our lives, (and we are not spring chickens) but this pizza surpassed them all! It was not greasy, the crust was crisp, without being burned, there was the perfect amount of sauce, spread out to the edges of the crust, and plentiful toppings. We will absolutely be back! ”
“ Croghan's best pizza place. Good food and service!! ”
“ Great food! Very reasonable prices! Go try it yourself! ”
“ Best place in Lewis County to get pizza and calzones, by far. They even left a small piece of broccoli on my girlfriend’s calzone as garnish when we ordered two so that we knew them apart. ”